Treats are one of the simplest ways we show our dogs love. Whether it's rewarding good behavior, reinforcing training, or just because they gave us that look, treats play a big role in everyday life as dog parents.

But here's the thing, not all dog treats are created equal. If you've ever flipped over a bag and struggled to pronounce half the ingredients, you're not alone. Billie has taste-tested plenty of treats over the years (purely for research purposes, obviously), and what we've learned is this: not all treats are created equal.

Let's break down some common ingredients found in dog treats, the potential long-term effects they can have on your pup, and why so many companies still use them in the first place.

Why "Questionable" Ingredients Are So Common in Dog Treats

Before diving into specific ingredients, it's important to understand why they exist in pet products at all.

Many mass-produce treats are designed to be:

• Shelf-stable for long periods of time
• Extremely inexpensive to manufacture
• Visually appealing to humans
• Consistent in flavor, texture, and appearance

To achieve this, companies often rely on artificial additives, fillers, and preservatives. While these ingredients may make production easier and cheaper, they don't always support a dog's long-term health.

1. Artificial Colors & Dyes

Common Examples: Red 40, Yellow 5 Blue 2

Artificial dyes are added for one reason only: to make treats look more appealing on the shelf. Dogs don't actually care if their treat is bright red or neon green, but humans do.

Why Companies Use Them:

• Improves visual appeal
• Creates brand consistency
• Make treats stand out in packaging

Potential Long-Term Effects:

• May contribute to behavioral sensitivity in some dogs
• Possible links to allergic reactions or skin irritation
• Zero nutritional value

Billie's Rule: If it looks like candy, it probably doesn't belong in a dog treat.

Learn more about Artificial Colors in Pet Food!

2. Chemical Preservatives

Common Examples: BHA, BHT, Ethoxyquin

These preservatives are used to extend shelf life and prevent fats from going rancid.

Why Companies Use Them:

• Longer shelf life = less waste
• Lower production costs
• Allows treats to sit in warehouses and stores for longer

Potential Long-Term Effects:

While research is ongoing, these preservatives have raised concerns due to:

• Possible links to liver and kidney stress
• Accumulation in the body over time
• Increased concern when consumed daily rather than occasionally

Many pet parents now seek treats preserved with natural alternatives liked mixed tocopherols (vitamin E) or rosemary.

Learn more about Dangerous Pet Food Preservatives!

3. Meat By-Products Without Clear Sourcing

Common Examples: Meat By-Product, Animal Digest 

Ingredients like "meat by-product" or "animal digest" don't tell you what part of the animal is being used, or even which animal it came from.

Why Companies Use Them:

• Very inexpensive protein source
• Allows flexibility in sourcing
• Maximizes use of leftover animal parts

Potential Long-Term Effects:

• Inconsistent nutritional value
• Harder to digest for some dogs
• Less transparency for pet parents
• Exposes dog with allergies

Clear, named proteins (like chicken, beef, or salmon) make it easier to understand exactly what you're feeding your dog.

Learn more about meat by-products in pet food!

4. Excessive Fillers

Common Examples: Corn, Wheat, Soy

Fillers are often used to bulk up treats while keeping costs low.

Why Companies Use Them:

• Cheap and widely available
• Improve texture and shape
• Increase volume without increasing cost

Potential Long-Term Effects:

• Minimal nutritional benefit
• May contribute to digestive upset or sensitivities
• Can displace higher-quality ingredients

Not every dog reacts poorly to fillers, but they rarely add meaningful value to treats.

Learn more about how fillers are harmful to dogs!

5. Added Sugars & Sweeteners

Dogs don't need added sugar, period.

Why Companies Use Them:

• Improves taste instantly
• Encourages repeat buying
• Enhances smell and texture

Potential Long-Term Effects:

• Weight gain
• Dental issues
• Blood sugar fluctuations

Some sweeteners, like xylitol, are extremely dangerous and should never be present in dog treats.

Learn more about how artificial sweeteners can harmful your dog!

6. Vague "Natural Flavors"

"Natural flavors" sounds harmless, but it is a broad term that can hide low-quality ingredients.

Why Companies Use Them:

• Avoids listing specific ingredients
• Protects proprietary formulas
• Allows flexibility in sourcing

Potential Long-Term Effects:

• Less transparency
• Harder to identify sensitivities
• Makes ingredient lists harder to trust

Learn more about what "Natural Flavors" means on dog food and treat labels.

Why We Choose Simpler Ingredients (And Why Billie Bites Exist)

Billie doesn't need flashy packaging or artificial flavor enhancers to get excited about treats. He just wants something that taste good and makes him feel good afterwards.

That's why Billie Bites are made with:

• Simpler, recognizable ingredients
• Clear protein sources
• No artificial colors, preservatives, or unnecessary fillers

We believe dog treats should support your dog's health, not compromise it over time. Billie Bites were created to be treats you can feel confident giving to your pup everyday! Whether it's for training, enrichment, or just because your dog is a good boy.

Shop Billie Bites Here!

The Long-Term View Matters

Many questionable ingredients won't cause immediate problems, which is why they often go unnoticed. The concern lies in daily exposure over time. Small choices add up, especially for dogs who enjoy treats everyday.

Choosing better ingredients helps support:

• Healthy digestion
• Steady energy levels
• Skin and coat health
• Overall well-being

The Bottom Line

Not all dog treats are created equal, and learning how to read ingredient labels is one of the simplest ways to support your dog's long-term health.

Treats should be a happy part of your dog's day, not something you second-guess. Billie's philosophy is simple: if you can't recognize and ingredient, it probably doesn't belong in your dog's treat.

More Blogs

How to Protect Your Dog's Paws in Winter

Before heading outside this winter, make sure your pup's paws are protected from cold temps, ice, and salt

10 Healthy and Safe Snacks for Your Pup

Looking for everyday snack ideas beyond the holidays? Here are 10 healthy and safe snacks your pup will love year-round.

7 Grooming Tips Every New Dog Owner Should Know

If you're a newer dog parent, don't miss our grooming tips to keep your pup feeling their best year-round.

How Dogs Positively Impact Our Mental Health

Dogs can help lower stress, reduce feelings on loneliness, and encourage healthier routines. Read more about how dogs paw-stively impact our mental health!